Updating post from Reddit.

3
QUESTION
Posted by Front-Praline-4564 1 week ago
How many of you are managing your own rentals - and glad you've avoided estate agents - if so, why?

Hi all!

TLDR: I'd like to understand why you prefer managing your own properties opposed to going through estate agents?

For context, this is my original post, long story short, launched my own rental marketplace 48 hours ago and am surprised and humbled about the positive feedback I've received, but one thing that stood out to me however is that I've not really received a lot of feedback from landlords who like to manage their own rentals and properties. I'd like to understand what were the primary reasons that made you want to move away from estate agents and self-manage ?

Appreciate the feedback in advance, and thanks for your time!

// Vai

24
8
Posted by Lit-Up 1 week ago

Agents are mediocre people doing a mediocre job, who should have stayed in school rather than fallen into this job, where they fundamentally don't care about who rents your property, inflate repair costs for their own benefit, and so on.

Reply
2
Posted by Buzzing-Around247 1 week ago

Yep. One let a tenant live in winter with a broken boiler for six weeks. Criminal offence for me as well as them. Gave rude insulting reply to me and no reply to tenant. Plumber’s bill doubled.

Reply
6
Posted by MortimerMan2 1 week ago

Self management is super easy. Like, child's play.

Personally I use an agent for finding a tenant, and I have the final say. I CBA to take a couple of days off work to watch a procession of hopeless candidates trudge through. Let the agent find the diamond in the rough and draw up the paperwork.

Once they're in, never hear anything generally.

Reply
3
Posted by Buzzing-Around247 1 week ago

You have to find the diamond the agent could not care less

Reply
2
Posted by RagerRambo 1 week ago

It's a nice looking platform, but fundamentally doesn't change anything. I self manage so only use an agency for finding tenants, referencing etc. Industry cost is around 7% for this, around one month's rent. This obviously includes them handling the viewings communications etc. which is the most expensive part. Think about a tenant that's accepted an offer but not signed the agreement. So what your app notifies me that's the case? I need someone to speak to the tenant and find out are they going to sign the paperwork, if there are issues, and feel them out to see if they are wasting time.

Your platform isn't offering that but charging 5%?

I agree fully that estate agents are on the whole mostly incompetent greedy subhumans, that take all the reward, with none of the risk, but until the robots can handle the viewings and chasing up then your platform is taking on the likes of openrent, which is long established and positively reviewed from my limited interactions with it.

Good luck with it though. Competition is a good thing.

Reply
1
Posted by Front-Praline-4564 1 week ago

Appreciate the engagement, and the kind words!

From what I understand, your main focus is on that initial tenant acquisition phase! I can go into how we make that as streamlined as possible, however it sounds like you're not our target demographic! We won't be able to automate viewings, or anything like that, and it seems you still go to an estate agency to handle that initial process of finding a tenant! Our fees only go up to 5% if you pay them monthly, upfront fees stand at 3% :).

Reply
3
Posted by Ex_Dev 1 week ago

Saw your post on the React subreddit yesterday and took a look. It wasn't fully clear what you would be getting from the pricing fees. Is it just a Contract/Right-To-Rent checks and the deposit scheme. I currently use an agent and pay a monthly fee (after a hefty fee to find a tenant too!), so once this contract is up will likely manage on my own but just use an agent to find a tenant and do all the checks/deposit scheme. What is the difference with your product vs. OpenRent for example? They look to be established, cheap (compared to Estate Agent) and do advertising to all platforms.

Does your product incur a monthly fee like an Estate Agent still?

Reply
1
Posted by Front-Praline-4564 1 week ago

Some valid points!! I’m currently implementing some feedback I’ve received from people, I’ll post an update that should hopefully answer many of your concerns in the next 24 hours! 🙏

Reply
2
Posted by Buzzing-Around247 1 week ago

Ooh gobbledygook estate agent speak “demographic”. You cannot compete with Openrent. I pick tenants and show around myself.

Reply
2
Posted by Front-Praline-4564 1 week ago

You seem nice ☺️ wishing you the best!

Reply
2
Posted by Muchtenting96 1 week ago

I only have 1 at the moment and I self manage and it works really well, however I do live relatively close. If i was to have 10 plus I would probably start using an agent or if I moved away

Reply
1
Posted by Front-Praline-4564 1 week ago

Understandable, that would take away from living your life, I imagine, having to coordinate 10 properties yourself! A question for you, do you not think the role could be reduced to an administrative role of a personal assistant instead of an estate agent?

Reply
3
Posted by No_Purchase_3214 1 week ago

My wife and I live abroad and have 5 properties in our portfolio currently. We are still able to manage them without the need of an agent. Our experience with agents is that they do very little and still come to us with any issues, so we really struggle to see any benefit to them at all. We are hoping to keep adding a couple properties per year and eventually this may become unmanageable but for now it’s really fine.

Reply
1
Posted by Muchtenting96 1 week ago

Yeah potentially, the I could just use an agent for the set up of the tenancy

Reply
2
Posted by Icy_Pollution8761 1 week ago

If you're actually hoping to make a profit, and treat being a landlord like the actual business that it is, requiring your time and attention, then spending some of that slim margin on 3rd parties (including fancy websites) and farming out everything particular and sensitive about your own business to other people is not on the agenda. I see using a managing agent as something you do largely if you're some clueless 'accidental' who probably still has a mortgage on the property, got a 'consent' letter and just wants to shut their eyes and pretend it doesn't exist for a few years before they clock the house prices haven't ballooned, try sell it anyway, and find out what a S21 really entails and how much the smiley agent really knows and cares.... if you're getting a decent deal from a management setup you probably have a spread of outright owned assets and were able to negotiate, and have better things to do by that point, so the value of time outweighs the cost.

Reply
2
Posted by TickityTickityBoom 1 week ago

I’ve been a letting agent, however, having those skills I manage my own properties.

Reply
1
Posted by Randomn355 1 week ago

Used estate agent once.

Literally every single step they could have made a mistake on, they did.

And I got a shit tenant because they imparted none of the f2f cues.

Never again.

Reply
1
Posted by towelie111 1 week ago

Everybody is different, has a different amount of properties, different distances, different amount of free time, different DIY abilities etc. I’ve done both. Started self managing initially as I had more free time, as that free time has been taken up I’ve started passing them on, more so until the new rules come in place and we see how they actually pan out. I can no longer drop everything to focus on an issue, or travel to a property to view/fix arrange a fix, I just don’t have the time. In 10-15 years I anticipate I will have the time again, and will start self managing again. It really is free money for agents when the tenants are good, I know that.

Reply
1
Posted by daudder 1 week ago

The total cost in terms of cost savings in addition to improved service for both landlord and tenant makes it well worth the effort.

EAs not only charge exorbitant prices, but provide bad service. I do much better than them in terms of my tenants and provide myself with a much better service than they can. I am paying myself what I save on their fees and I get better tenants. I have had zero issues over ten years of letting, not even a late rent. My costs are lower since I do some repairs myself and manage my tradespeople well with no agent-uplifts or kickbacks, and my tenants are happy since I take care of them.

There was a learning curve and I had to invest in sourcing services I need and in my leases, notices etc., but now it's down to minimal effort.

Win-win all around.

Reply
1
Posted by Far-Professional5988 1 week ago

We have 2 properties and use an agent. They are excellent. In 10 years both properties have been let 99% of the time, excellent tenants and they sort out legals and repairs etc that I don't have the time or frankly the interest to bother with.

I know them at a personal level which helps I guess but they simply do what they charge me for, I'm happy to pay them.

Reply
1
Posted by Buzzing-Around247 1 week ago

Complete dishonesty, greed, incompetence that can get you inti legal trouble and stupidity and do not care a damn attitude plus very rude and ignorant. Rental law is now a minefield. I do not even take a deposit anymore. I see in cost of cleaning mending and refurbishment between tenancies. You have 24 hours to do it. Old tenants leave at noon and new ones in after noon next day.You must choose your tenant carefully and ask “would I like to invite this person into my home for supper?” If answer is no then do not bother. Go with your gut. My solicitor gave me the advice to never house women as they can get pregnant and you cannot get them out. Students are. fine as they leave.

Reply
2
Posted by phpadam 1 week ago

> My solicitor gave me the advice to never house women as they can get pregnant and you cannot get them out. Students are. fine as they leave.

Sex is one of 9 'protected characteristics' covered by discrimination law (Equality Act 2010). Your on a path to giving some lady a big payout.

Reply
1
Posted by opopkl 1 week ago

I had three properties. I used agents for finding and vetting tenants but other than that, I managed them all. Once you find electricians, plumbers and people who fix appliances, it's easy enough. For some reason, tradespeople seem to be quite keen on working with landlords rather than private tenants and there seem to be people who only work on rentals. All the agents are going to do is ring them anyway. One plumber told me that some agencies add 50% to his bill before passing then on to the landlord.

Also, if you establish a good relationship with your tenant, they're more likely to stay and to look after the property.

Reply
1
Posted by Ok-Assistant1958 1 week ago

Some agents add value for relatively low cost, others charge a ton of money to make your life more difficult.

If there was a management company that included some basic handy man services in the fee then that would make it more attractive, but I'm not paying £150+ a month for them to not be able to do anything but spend £100 of my money to pay someone to do the simplest of fixes. Like a tenant didn't know how to turn on a light and they were going to get an electrician to figure out how to turn the light on.

Reply